Expert reviews and tasting notes from our team of reviewers
347 reviews found
Review
Ron Colon High Proof Rum Blended Traditionalist Rum delivers a aged experience that earns its 8 out of 10 — a Jamaica ru...
Read more
Ash Carrington
December 21, 2025
Review
Foursquare's Exceptional Cask Selections are widely regarded as the finest rums produced in Barbados today — pure, undoc...
Read more Ash Carrington
December 20, 2025
Review
A aged rum from Caribbean that punches above its weight. Chairman's Reserve Legacy Single Traditional Blended Rum earns ...
Read more
Review
Five years in the Caribbean, five years in Spain in PX sherry casks — Dos Maderas' 5+5 is an unashamedly sweet, sherry-d...
Read more
Review
A compelling aged rum from Real McCoy that delivers real craftsmanship — an essential addition to any collection.
Read more
Review
This aged offering from Guyana showcases the best of Enmore 1990 / 32 Year Old / Rum Sponge Edition 24 — aromatic, well-...
Read more
Review
The pinnacle of the Admiral Rodney range — nine- to twelve-year-old column-distilled rums blended from bourbon barrels i...
Read more
Review
Doorly's 12 is produced by Foursquare but sold at a fraction of the ECS price — making it one of the most astonishing ba...
Read more Ash Carrington
December 15, 2025
Review
Our editors review Glen Grant Exploration No.1 / Rum Cask Finish — a aged rum from Scotland bottled at 48% ABV. An outst...
Read more Ash Carrington
December 13, 2025
Review
We rate Planteray Isle of Fiji Single Traditional Blended Rum a strong 7/10. This aged expression from Fiji offers real ...
Read more
Review
A aged rum from Panama that punches above its weight. Panama-Pacific Reserva 5 Year Old Single Traditional Column Still ...
Read more Ash Carrington
December 13, 2025
Review
Our editors review Planteray PXXO 20th Anniversary Rum — a aged rum from Barbados bottled at 40% ABV. A well-crafted spi...
Read more